HomeThe BookArticlesAsk your question
Parenting advice Feedback on advice

Parenting advice

Sample parenting questions and responses

Check what other parents are interested in and ask your own question!

5 year old terror
Stubborn 4 year old
How to raise a 1 year old into a loving and confident adult?
14 year old always in trouble
She was a good girl
3 year old crier
8 year old hates staying quiet

5 year old terror

Describe your child.

My nephew is a 5 year old terror: mean, spiteful, and angry. He can also be kind and considerate when he isn't around other kids

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

My nephew who lives with me for the past 6 months has taken to stealing things and hiding them in his room. So far he has taken my cell phone, my keys and some money from my wallet. I have taken the time to sit down with him and explain why he shouldn't steal. He acts like he understands and the stealing stopped for a week. Yesterday he stole another kid's bike. I'm afraid he is going to steal something of value from one of the neighbors.

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

In the morning about 5 - 10 minutes when we get ready for the day, 5-10 minutes at the end of the day when I put him to bed

How good is your child?

8, he can be a sweetheart when other kids aren't around.

How honest is your child?

9, he admits that he has taken things without permission

How kind are you to your child?

9, I practice patience and kindness with him. I don't holler at hiim or anything.

How fair are you to your child?

10, I believe I am fair in that he is disciplined when he does something wrong.

 

Here is our analysis of the child.

From your description of the situation with your nephew we conclude that the child was not raised by you. So you have to deal with the result of someone's upbringing result. And unfortunately the child is spiteful and angry, which says that in his five years of life the child saw a lot of meanness and anger from adults around him. That means the child has a great need for kindness and goodness to shape a new, right image of his self and the world. You can make a difference in his life as you describe yourself patient and fair person.  But you must accept the fact that to change another person is much harder than to raise him from the beginning. So he will not change fast.

 

What exactly can you do to begin influencing him for better? Since you have only few minutes a day, you can only rely on your faith in this child: because you have a faith that he is good and honest enough. You must change your own fear of the child stealing habits into your conviction that he is a good and honest man. The point is that he is only 5 year old child and to give him a label of having stealing habits is the same as to spoil the whole child's life in advance! It is very dangerous fear. Soloveychik says: Don't even dare to suspect your child! He may acquire the image of himself as a thief and, believe me, he will make all your fears come true! So, stop fearing, don't be afraid, stop labeling him even if to yourself. Keep your faith in him as an honest boy. He is not a thief! Why? Because he is a good boy and he is your nephew!!! What if he does? No, he won't. Don't believe it. Defend your child even if he does, guard him dignity, when possible. If you can't do that because the fact is obvious, refer to it as a stupid mistake, or accident or alike, again and again - guard the child's dignity. Believe in him! Every minute you are with him, give him to know that you trust him, you believe in him, and praise whatever good qualities he has in his little life. Inspire him to explore his best talents, inspire him with the good stories, great heroes. This would be our advice.  Good luck!

 

   Ask your own question  Back to Top

Stubborn 4 year old

Describe your child.

4 years old, son. Smart, stubborn.

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

Daycare, refused to go inside because he lost a toy, tried to trick me into taking him back home. I had to physically carry him in after two failed attempts of having him walk in himself. He ran to the car, yelled he hates me. Got him in, teacher had to restrain him, walked out. He was crying

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

1 hour

How good is your child?

He is good with other people, but very incorrigible with me.

How honest is your child?

He does not lie, he is very honest.

How kind are you to your child?

I am very kind, I show him and tell him I love him. I tend to spoil him and give him whatever he wants.

How fair are you to your child?

He always gets his way.

Here is our analysis of the situation.

Your son is in ages called "terrible twos," which last from 2 to 4 year old. This is time when children realize their selves, their identities. Usually they try to do everything by themselves and often encounter parents forbidding will. Those with the strong character are usually seen as stubborn, when in fact they desire to be independent. However, parents must remember that this difficult time will soon be replaced with very nice older ages, and it isn't worth it to spoil the relationship with little children.

 

By the age of 5 children form in their minds a very important image of themselves, and of the world. Especially important for them is mother's attitude. If you want your son to have less conflicts with people in the future, in his adulthood, you need to make sure he gets enough security of heart and intelligence at the age he is now. What does it mean?

 

Heart security means that a child is loved. You may think you do everything he needs to learn about your love, but according to the situation you described he doesn't get enough of your love. That is why he behaves so desperately, hoping you would protect; when you bring him to daycare and he fights to keep from entering, his sense of security is shaken because the teacher holds him back as though he is a prisoner attempting to run away. As this is going on he watches as his main means of security turns her back and walks away from him.

 

Intelligence security means a child is trusted. It seems to us that you trust him not enough, as you describe him as stubborn and incorrigible. This is what you believe he is, and according to parenting science, he becomes what you believe he is. Not vice versa. This is what your son senses and what he is trying to fight with. Your son senses injustice in your faith in him, so he is upset because about that. You say that you are very kind with him, tell and show him that you love him, yes, it is how you see the situation. He might disagree, even though he can't express his feelings. But his behavior with you tells us that something that you do is unfair to this boy. That is why you two often struggle for power.

 

Our advice would be:

Gain your child's trust: talk to him, tell that you are upset too, and ask for forgiveness for that you couldn't take him home when he wanted, if you really feel so.

Cheer your child up! (Before that cheer yourself up, be happy, try to be happy, find cause for humor etc.)

 

However, giving your child whatever he wants doesn't mean love. Often children ask for material things because they feel not enough of parent's love, you know, big heart, generosity, magnanimity sometimes, some soul work, where you feel your child's desires and by yielding to him you escalate his dignity. But just giving "things" instead is kind of "payment" for not being able to feel his soul. This "payment" children accept as a substitute for their need for love and justice, but substitute is not a real replacement.

 

This stuff may seem to you awkward, heavy, too philosophical. We tried to be as truthful as possible, rather than be nice. We apologize if the analysis seems to be wrong due to the lack of information given. In any case, thank you for trusting us. The work we suggest takes great patience, which is a sign of love too.

 

Good luck!

This is a chapter we suggest you read from our website: chapter 24, book1part2, which describes a child, who said "I hate you" to his father. We also would suggest to read chapter 14 of book3part2 about "things" and money.

 

  Ask your own question  Back to Top

 

How to raise a 1 year old into a loving and confident adult? 

Describe your child.

I year old daughter

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

I am a single mother and want to give her the skills to become a loving and confident adult

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

I work full-time so definitely NOT ENOUGH!

How good is your child?

6

How honest is your child?

n/a

How kind are you to your child?

7

How fair are you to your child?

7

Here is an analysis from that limited data you provided answering our little questionnaire.

 

One year old girl. She needs loving and trusting (fair) environment. If you work and someone provides that environment you shouldn't worry that you have little time with her. As long as you appear, time to time, and infect her with your happy emotions and great faith that she is a very good and smart girl. This is enough in your situation.

Two needs children have: need for security and need for development. You make sure these two needs are satisfied. If your child doesn't behave right, in your opinion, it means the child's needs were not met properly, or one of the child's needs not satisfied. However, security and development don't only apply to physical security and development. Heart and intelligence - these two are important as well: security of heart: feeling of being loved, development of heart: ability to love other people; security of intelligence - feeling of being trusted, and development of intelligence - ability to trust others. This stuff may seem complicated, but this is how it is: complex stuff cannot be explained in one sentence. However, this is basics which will influence all the rest of the child's life. You may find different parenting books and advices, but most of them will give examples of the same things, without mentioning it. But in order to be smart mother you need to know how to explain them. Then you can make right decisions and not be dependent on other people's advices.

The fact of single motherhood doesn't matter too much for raising a good adult. Time too is not very important. Your faith and love - this what matters. However, we all need to learn about love and faith in our children.

From your answer, I see that you don't think you child is good for 100%, why? As for honesty, you need proof of her honesty. This tells me that you don't believe that your child is already a decent human being. Here is your faith in your child. Face it. She senses that and that this is not fair for her. She also senses that she is not good enough for her mother. Later this will show up in a behavior and you will prove yourself your own belief. Better to believe in your child first and than see the result later!

Good luck!

 

 Ask your own question  Back to Top

14 year old always in trouble (The parent who wrote this letter possibly didn't  receive the answer, as email address was not correct.) 

Describe your child.

Age 14, my daughter, she's smart, funny, beautiful, an only child- she slightly overweight, outspoken and shy at the same time hot tempered, basically thoughtful and kind-she lies a lot and always in trouble for something or other, messy in her personal habits

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

She does poor in school, is smart mouthed with her parents but not others, she busted my lip with a cell phone yesterday because she was mad , she won't clean up after herself or do her homework.

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

8 hours

How good is your child?

5

How honest is your child?

1

How kind are you to your child?

9

How fair are you to your child?

7

Here is an analysis from the limited information you gave us.

 

Your point is clear: you want your daughter be nice girl, successful in study and confident with herself, so that she would let you live your peaceful life. But she doesn't. Why? Does she want make your life complicated? I don't think so.

 

If we were able to listen to your daughter side, we might end up with a different story. She feels not secured and therefore doesn't have a good mood for developing her talents in full. The insecurity doesn't mean physical or financial. It means, she doesn't feel loved enough because she knows she is not good enough for her parents. Also she knows that parents don't trust her because she believes her parents believe that she is a liar, though it seems that nobody is really interested in the reason why she has to lie. The reason is that she is not secured! Nobody believes her!

 

"We don't believe in children not because they are bad, but they become bad because we don't believe in them." S.Soloveychik

 

If you feel same way you would be desperate too. Especially if someone around constantly remind you about your failures.

 

At teen age, children are tormented by their helplessness, their imperfections. In fact their souls strive to pursue high ideals, but they would only trust people who don't judge them, don't nag them constantly but accept them, those who love them.  Unfortunately, if they don't have such people around, they have to merely survive, trying to defend their fragile dignities from tactless attacks from adults. Therefore they enter the power struggle with adults. But there is no winner in power struggles between parents and their children, both lose.

 

The situation you described is the result of so called evil tunnel: someone began encroach another person's dignity; the other person responded the same way: usually saying something nasty back. The first side, being indignant, continued attack and the war continued until it reaches the final point: in your case it is broken lip. What to do? Who must stop the evil tunnel? - The person who is mature enough to stop it. The person who loves more.

 

Advice: 1. Forgive your daughter, for the sake of her goodness, for the gift you were once blessed 14 years ago. Imagine, inside of her soul she suffers too. She's mistaken, but you've mistaken too. Find where exactly. Accept it and then it will be easier to forgive your daughter.

2. Think of how you can help her with her "silly" problems (poor study, overweight etc). For her those problems she struggles (not confidence with other people) are not silly, they are terrible, they are serious. Ask her about them, when she feels like talking.

3. Leave her alone (for a while). You will be surprised that your child can cope with her life, if she were given a respect.

4. Don't focus on chores. Life isn't all about it. Chores, clean ups and other good habits, if not acquired in earlier ages, will not be possible to be taught at teen age. One of the laws of parenting says that chores are the worst and thankless thing in our relationship with teenagers, who didn't learn that at their early ages. If you still try you risk to ruin your relationship with your child. But you would like to have a good relationship with your grown up daughter in a few years from now, wouldn't you?

 

    Ask your own question  Back to Top 

She was a good girl  (The parent who wrote this letter possibly didn't  receive the answer, as email address was not correct.) 

Describe your child.

6 yrs.old. daughter, she was a good girl, polite. matured and sweet

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

sometimes, she doesn't follow my rules, she always sleep late

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

alsmost everyday

How good is your child?

8

How honest is your child?

8

How kind are you to your child?

i am not so kind, because i want her to be independent, but i see to it that i can give her a talk

How fair are you to your child?

very fair i guess

Here is our analysis from that little data we have:

6 years old. She was a good girl, polite, mature and sweet (hint: now she is a bad girl, impolite, immature and nasty.) And, sometimes she doesn't follow your rules (Do you think she always should follow your rules? Would you always follow someone's rules yourself?). She always sleep late. Always - is a dangerous word. If you say so to children, they accept it as their own label - "So, there is nothing to do, I am such a sleeper, a bad girl."

 

Let's begin with the basics: children have two basic needs: for security and development. This applies both to physical and emotional sides. If a child behaves wrong it means that her needs are not met, nothing else. Emotional security - heart and intelligence security - is a feeling to be loved and trusted. Emotional development -  heart and intelligence development - is an ability to love and trust. From the described situation your daughter doesn't feel loved and trusted (anymore), because she feels your mother's attitude: that you think of her as a bad girl since some time. You judge your daughter and make conclusion about her after she shows you her behavior. But this is a most common mistake: parents think that they are to judge, to control, to manage, to command, to teach and to rule their children. Perhaps you yourself would not like if your own parents have this attitude to you in your childhood. So you can imagine that children resist this attitude too. Why? Because this attitude encroaches children's dignity. Any encroachment is evil, desire to suppress someone's character is evil. On the contrary- desire to enlighten someone's dignity, esteem, increases value, increasing dignity - is goodness. So, the solution is - change your faith in your child first: she was and she IS a good girl NOW and she will be a good girl always for you, because she is.

Experts of good human relationship says: treat your children, your spouse, your siblings as they are the most important people in the world, because "they are." (Bryan Tracy)  This is truth and you will be surprised when you change your own attitude to your daughter.

 

"We don't believe in children not because they are bad, but they become bad because we don't believe in them." S.Soloveychik

 

The sleep problem may sign a good healthy stage of physical growth, when her body needs to sleep a lot. Or, it could sign a depression, which followed your changed attitude and her sense of not being loved and trusted any more.

 

You have a lot of time to communicate with your daughter: ask her about her feelings, about her life, interests, "secrets," or tell her about your "secrets," make your heart hearing her heart. On the other hand, leave her alone for a while. It is not necessary to nag over a child all the day. She deserves some privacy and rest too.

 

If we parents want our children to be independent this doesn't give us a right to be rude with children. Independence doesn't come this way. It is a law. The goal (independence) will be impossible to reach, if we try to reach it at children's expense (by forcing them, by being not kind with them, by letting them cry, by letting them feel bad about them). So, the only way is left: moral means to reach our goal: what kind of means are available: attracting, involving, playing, talking when they are feeling like talking, listening to them! You will be surprised when you begin listen to your little girl. This all and much more requires a lot of soul work, but this all then will be very rewarding because this all is called love.

  

   Ask your own question  Back to Top

3 year old crier 

Describe your child.

My daughter is 3 years old, extremely smart, and very obsessed with cleanliness, she is very shy, but loves outdoors, enjoys reading stories, and has a very big imagination and create her own stories.

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

She cries a lot, since she was born we had such a difficult time with her, and now she is 3 and still. She wakes up crying all the time, anything happens she would cry...she is very polite and obedient but this crying is very annoying, and people are getting annoyed from her as well.

What is your parental goal?

I want her to start dealing with things without the tears and be better around others

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

about 2-3 hrs a day

How good is your child?

8

How honest is your child?

10

How kind are you to your child?

7

How fair are you to your child?

9

What state/country are you from?

uae

How did you find us?

internet

Your daughter is a very interesting girl. You did a good job raising her with a great imagination and creativity. It is a greatest advantage, which you can also use for solving her crying problem.

 

Of course the data you provided is not enough and we have some questions to clarify your situation: what exactly happens before she cries?

 

We suggest, ask her about her feelings and most important, listen to her answer! Listen to her stories, which may tell you a lot. Perhaps she has internal difficulties, which make her afraid of something that you are not aware of.

 

Of course crying is annoying, but put yourself in her shoes - do you think she is willing to cry, do you think she cries because she wants to? No, at her age she can't pretend, or want to be unhappy. Naturally children strive for happiness. Most likely she is very sensitive to things, which you as her mother and other adults don't want to notice, or are not able to notice, because of lack of sensitivity.

 

Your girl needs you, your love and acceptance. However, recently you may show your frustration about her crying and she receives it as she isn't good enough for you, which makes her have a real reason to be unhappy.

 

Don't be embarrassed too much about what people think of you when your daughter cries. Think in advance how can you distract your daughter from feeling unhappy. Make her happy!

Be attentive in the morning - how she wakes up - what makes her unhappy? She is such a lovely girl! How can it ever be possible that she is afraid of something? Be as tender as possible, praise her for a being obedient and clean. This is a blessing! Many parents complain that their children didn't learn to be clean, but your daughter is an example of a girl, who will not give her mother a reason to be ashamed. So be proud! Obsessive behavior may be the result of her great imagination, that is a gift, which, if properly developed, may bring her a lot of happiness in the future, because imagination and inquisitiveness are gifts of soul. She is extremely smart. So she senses everything that you think about her. So she knows that you don't consider her 100% good girl. That is a parental mistake. You need to believe in your daughter, that she is 100% good (and a normal, stable, strong) girl, instead of judging from what you see. Remember:

We don't believe in children not because they are bad, but they become bad because we don't believe in them. S.Soloveychik

 

So, please give us more information if you think we are wrong in our analysis of the situation.

 

Patience is a virtue. Crying will stop when the your girl will get enough of what she needs. Find out what she needs! Be patient. She deserves your patience, she is such an adorable girl!

 

   Ask your own question  Back to Top

8 year old hates staying quiet 

Describe your child.

My son is 8 yrs old going to nine in February. He is a very busy boy. He is always doing something and he does not know how to be quiet for a minute. He wants to have something to do all the time and gets bored very easily. At school he is quite good and he competes in swimming and earns medals He does not have any brothers and sisters but he has loads of activities in his life. I love him with all my heart but he sometimes irritates me a lot.

Describe the situation, where you need advice.

He always wants to be the centre of attraction and he hates staying quiet.

What is your parental goal?

Make him listen more and obey us more. He is always ignoring me.

How much time during a day do you communicate with your child?

From the afternoon onwards, till 9.

How good is your child?

Good heart but sometimes rude. 5

How honest is your child?

7

How kind are you to your child?

7

How fair are you to your child?

9

What state/country are you from?

Malta

How did you find us?

Till now I think you are helpful as suggested by a friend.

Children do irritate us parents sometimes. But we need to remember that irritation is the first sign of vanishing love. (If you look inside yourself at the time of being irritated you find no love in your heart, because when you are irritated you hate your child. Think about that.) However, we all learn to love.

What helps, is to think about the child: is he guilty? Is this - his genuine intention to make my life worse? Is your son guilty that he doesn't have siblings to play with? Is his energetic nature has an evil intention to make me miserable?

 

According to little information you provided I see that your son is a very good and healthy boy in terms of his busy life (and you did a good job raising him as such!) He is at age when everything interests him and his imagination. Use his imagination to positive activities, which would satisfy you both: invent quiet games, play intellectual games (crosswords etc), invite neighbor kids to play, etc. A lot to think for you if you want your son grow with his urgent NEEDS to be met. Otherwise it is unfair to your child.

 

Now, think: if you are not "kind" to your son for 100%, why can't you expect your son be "rude" to you back? Who is in charge for your relationship with your child? Usually it is an adult who is in charge. You need to learn about children needs (for heart and intelligence security and development, which is a huge topic, explained in S.Soloveychik's book Parenting For Everyone. )

 

There is another thing though: you can just shut the boy's mouse up and threat him by punishing etc, etc. But in the long run you might not wish these methods to be used as your son may lose his interest, which is the best natural gift, which you parent must use creatively to form the child's spirit, instead of killing it.

If you have anything to add to the picture welcome to write to us more.

 
 

 Ask your own question  Back to Top

Now ask your own question or contact us to order the book where we derive our wisdom.


Home  ·  Book's Content  ·  Articles  ·  Contact us  ·  Sitemap
Copyright ©2006 Aubanova&Dull